Dadiji coming in Gulzar's body, like BapDada, certainly takes a bit of swallowing, but the way for this was prepared earlier (so there is at least some consistency), as per Avyakt BapDada, 6th September 2007 (12 days after she left the body) (see
http://BapDada.yondbe.com/versere/page/62 ) :
"Dadi will come to meet you. A date has not been fixed yet, but she will definitely come."
That Murli also said:
Dadi is having to play a special part in the corporeal world for name's sake in order to carry out a special, unique and lovely essential task. However, Dadi's birth and her task are extremely unique. Baba will come and tell the detail of that later. BapDada too has to play the part that is fixed in the drama, and enable others to play their part. Baba will tell later what the uniqueness (alokikta) of this is.
And made good on this promise in a trance message 29th November 2007: see
http://BapDada.yondbe.com/versere/page/583, confirming that the soul of Dadiji was then "in the womb" preparing for rebirth in the Advance Party on Earth.
However, these messages provoke more questions than they provide answers. As ex-l says,
In my experience, they had no answers to such lines of questions .
Add to this, in the most recent Avyakt Murli of 3rd April 2012 (
http://BapDada.yondbe.com/versere/page/426), there was a very confusing passage, where Dadi Gulzar apparently started channeling
herself from the Subtle Regions ... There was clear confusion from the translators (as per the live video, available on youtube) as to what on earth was going on ... So, this "BapDadi" performance now, simply moves us further into a strange and confusing dreamlike world where subtle characters merge and morph into each other, giving us a chorus of voices from the Subtle Regions via Dadi Gulzar ...
Personally I am stumped at coming up with any explanation as to how the soul of Dadiji can perform in the Subtle Region as her old (BK) self whilst apparently simultaneously reborn in a new body and life on Earth - yes, she could still be emerged in the Subtle Region (it does seem that absolutely anything can happen there!), but in her old form?
The plot thickens to the point where it comes down to simple faith: just believe what you are told, however far-fetched. Logic will not support this stuff - not even fuzzy logic - and the BKs seem to have no desire to even ask the questions, let alone find answers.
It feels to me that the whole ball of wax is melting ...
Who needs knowledge or understanding, when you can simply accept whatever you are told, unquestioningly, and
It would be great if some Hindi-speaking yogi type out there can prove me wrong, and actually explain what is going on ... perhaps a PBK ... but I am not holding my breath. BapDada clearly cannot or will not provide answers that make any sense.
Certainly, to claim that the BKs (or BapDada come to that) have "the only true knowledge" seems a nonsense. They have dharna and they do service, and some are yogis, but their "knowledge" seems to consist of "follow the Father", and "let's make it up as we go along". Indians may be happy with this, but for westerners, it is too much to swallow.
Better just to observe in amazement (or ignore it all, if that is your preference), and let go of trying to comprehend the incomprehensible ... (I wish I could ...).