Smonika and the "logic" of there being a Supreme Soul
Posted: 21 Jan 2013
ex-l wrote:"Typical, a BK joins the forum and the first thing they do is lie about their connection to the BKWSU.
First and foremost of all. I am not a BK ... ma'm, a supporter of their ideology rather, who's been studying this spiritual knowledge for some time now. I accidently stumbled upon this forum while browsing some of BKs' "genuine" links n after going through some of the blogs posted here, I feel, it's worth joining, for it provides some debatable points. :).
"affinity to the BKWSU: media or academic"
wouldn't n M.phil student be considered under "academic"? or are there some other criteria(not stated clearly) being applied for categorizing the joiners?
"education subnormal by the quality of their writing, and logic"
probably you had better use "simple" because simplicity is often called subnormal when we can not take down something which doesn't involve any complexity. Logic is "art of reasoning" ... which has taken quite a circuitous route in your case, as is proved in your statement
"No, just because we might be "souls", there is no logic to state there might be one Supreme Soul. That is a BKism (as is "souls playing a role"). There could no no Supreme Soul, there could be a hierarchy of many supreme souls, as we are discussing elsewhere, god could be something entirely different from how the Brahma Kumaris conceive it.
Logic says there "should" be "a" Supreme Soul, for there can be just "one" to whom superlatives - ultimate, unique, perfect, epitome (etc) be applied! Even if there be many supreme souls, again the concept of "coordinator of all supremes" demands attention. Why the hypothesis of "oneness" is getting difficult to be taken down by you, I wonder. By the same logic, you would have denied having "one" brain in your body but as it is a scientifically proven fact, you would not like to challenge it!!! Even an atheist like "ALBERT EINSTEIN" conceded in some of his newly-found manuscripts that "there surely is some spiritual force governing this universe" but hard-core truth is still to be established by nowadays scientists. THE ONLY WAY WE ARE LEFT WITH TO GET UP TO THE TRUTH IS "OUR OWN" EXPERIENCE but if you failed to experience, no reasoning can satisfy you ever. Not even any scientific breakthrough which might some day validate this hypotheses!
"The purpose of this forum is for protecting non-BKs by exposing the true teachings of the BKWSU, helping individuals leave the BKWSU, or promoting the reform of the BKWSU. If you are not interested in one of those three, please leave now."
if you are a true reformer, my presence should not bother you.
thanx :)