Page 1 of 1

Brahmakumari legal cases in India

PostPosted: 02 Jun 2013
by ex-l
pawan_kr wrote:According to Brahmakumaris, they are receiving huge donations from their students who have donated the amount as 1 Rupee per student per day. Really !!!!!!!!!This statement was given to the court ...

From the topic Brahmakumaris and donations, our dear friend pawan_kr has opened up a huge can of BK worms, care of the excellent Indian Kanoon website ... oh, my goodness.

There are even more results to go through using Brahma Kumaris as a search subject.

So much for the BKs' squeaky clean imagine ... it appears they are no stranger to the Indian courts. Lots of tax related cases and appeals requesting cases being kicked out. It appears Ramesh Shah, now of Mount Abu, has been very busy with them.

But what was Criminal Petition No. 10071/2013 in the High Court of Karnataka, dated 21 January 2013 ...
Brahmakumari Nirmala, Brahmakumari Shamala, Brahmakumari Sharada

versus

Brahmakumari Mahalakshmi, Brahmakumari Bheemappa Madivalar, Brahmakumari Sunil Mugachi, Brahmakumari Shripad, Brahmakumari Surekha Habeeb, Brahmakumari Ratnamala, Brahmakumari Ushakiran and the State of Karnataka?

Sounds messy.

I see also records relating to,
It will take me some time to go through these links. If anyone else cares to investigate, I would be grateful.

Re: Brahmakumari legal cases in India

PostPosted: 03 Jun 2013
by ex-l
Here's another case where the BKs demanded 25 acres of valuable government land near Hyderabad on lease for a period of 30 years to build a center "free of charge". Land which was already leased by someone else.

Do the BKs' spiritual ethics not disallow them from benefiting where, "serious illegality and irregularity has been committed" in their favor? I wonder if there were BK followers in the local government supporting them?
the [Brahma Kumaris] addressed a letter dated 1-3-2001 to the Honourable Chief Minister, Government of Andhra Pradesh to sanction "a suitable land centrally located at Hyderabad at free of costs or at nominal charges" for construction of training centre having training Halls, Modern Audio Visual Library, Meditation Rooms, Spiritual Art Gallery, in house accommodation etc. The main aim of the said modem training centre is to motivate and educate the public at large to adopt the values, which will be helpful in all the fields of life.

It seems the BKs did not get it in the end ... "natural resources and properties are held by the government in trust for and on behalf of the people. The community is the owner of such resources. No government can be heard in saying that it can grant any government land on such terms as it deems fit to any person of its choice."
58. Serious illegality and irregularity has been committed in delivering the advance possession of the lands in question to [the Brahma Kumaris] and such delivery of advance possession is without any authority of law.

Advance possession has been delivered may be on paper contrary to the Alienation Rules as well as the Lease Rules. The very decision proposing to grant lease for a period of 30 years taken subsequent to delivery of possession is contrary to rules.

59. For all the aforesaid reasons, the decision of the government to grant lease of the land to respondents 5 and 6 is declared illegal and ultra vires. The decision is accordingly set aside. The action of the District Collector, Ranga Reddy District in delivering the advance possession of the land in question to respondents 5 and 6 is also set aside.

60. The petitioner industry, however, is not entitled for any renewal of lease in its favour. The land shall continue to vest in the government and the government shall resume the land and take over the same from the possession of respondents 5 and 6. The land for all purposes shall be treated as government land and vests in the government.

Re: Brahmakumari legal cases in India

PostPosted: 03 Jun 2013
by ex-l
We've discussed how the Brahma Kumaris regularly claim that they are not a religion or religious.

Here's a case where, to the government, they claimed
It was further stated in this representation that the institution is purely religious having various centres all over India

I thought Brahma had three heads, not two faces ...

Re: Brahmakumari legal cases in India

PostPosted: 03 Jun 2013
by Pink Panther
A long form radio report (either BBC or NPR) the other day was about the "Indian way" - i.e. bribery and corruption, and how the younger generations were revolting!

That is, the younger, especially better educated, people see this practice as holding society back and entrenching inequality (as the poor cannot afford to bribe - which is often needed to get your diploma or a driving licence or whatever), and many now refuse to take part in it.

They interviewed a number of young people who have left themselves disadvantaged by refusing to "play the game" , preferring to do what's right, and who often argue with their parents who insist that they should "play the game".

Agyani body-conscious souls have more moral fibre than those god-connected divine souls proclaiming Ram Raj it seems.