Sindhi Sikhs, an Amil connection?

for discussing revisions in the history of the Brahma Kumaris and updating information about the organisation
  • Message
  • Author
User avatar

ex-l

ex-BK

  • Posts: 10661
  • Joined: 07 Apr 2006

Sindhi Sikhs, an Amil connection?

Post28 Jul 2016

Tracing the roots of BK philosophy, questions arise about where and when the various influences and references in the BK teachings came from. I previously thought that the references to Guru Nanak and from Sikhism came much later, e.g. with the advent of leading BKs such as Nirwair in the 1950s.

This appears to be wrong.

BKism was born from the cloisters of the Bhaiband Sindhi community. The merchant Bhaibands were close to another jati (or caste) called the Amils who they used primarily as the trusted managers or accountants of their businesses, and it was amongst the two that the original Om Mandli members arose.

It turns out that many Amils, originally a Hindu sect, adopted Sikhism and many Hindu Sindhi women learned the Gurmukhī alphabet to enable them to read the Guru Granth Sahib. The Sikh scripture. Therefore, before Indian Independence and Partition, many non-Muslim Sindhis were actually Sehajdhari or Nanakpanthi Sikhs.

Records show that during the early 1900s, the Chief Khalsa Diwan of Amritsar sent out missionary groups to Sindh to work among the Sindhis. Over a period of 30 years, this missionary activity resulted in an increase from 1,000 Sindhis in 1901, to over 39,000 in 1941. A significant number in those days.

Therefore, it is likely that the Sikh influence upon BKism goes right back to its earliest days. Whether it arose due to Lekhraj Kirpalani being questioned from that point of view, or whether it was designed as a sales strategy to attract Sikh Sindhis to his side, or whether Lekhraj Kirpalani conceived of it as a part of his syncretic* approach (borrowing from other religions to create his master one), or whether it was just pick up unconsciously, is open to discussion.

The BKs, typical to cults, prefer to present their gurus teachings as being the original religious teachings of all religions; unique and whole, of which other religions - even those religions pre-dating it by centuries - borrow parts from. The original source of the teaching is present as being from "God" personally and directly rather than cobbled together from useful bits of other religions into something that sells.

Studying the business practises of the Bhaibands**, I tend to believe it was the latter. The Bhaibands were not creators but entrepreneurs. They bought the work of others cheaply, craftsmen and women, and then took it elsewhere, often internationally, to sell it elsewhere for high profits.

It is in this cultural practise that I believe BKism is rooted ... not with goods but with others ideas; taking them and reselling them elsewhere where they would appear unique, exotic, and attractive. What could be more "Buy low, Sell high" than religion?

I do not believe Lekhraj Kirpalani would have lost his extremely materially successful business sense, just because he believed himself to be god. Especially, in the 1950s, after the original failed predictions of Destruction and the End of the World, when his and their fortunes are said to have run out.

With a community of unskilled, uneducated but highly indoctrinated and regimented women to sustain, what else could he had turn to as a business to support them ... but the business of religion?

And how much did the necessities of the business of religion as an revenue stream alter the design of the religion they were selling?

At some point in the mid-1950s, Lekhraj Kirpalani revolutionised the BK religion. From being their god Prajapati Brahma, Vishnu, Krishna and Narayan combined ... he decided he was not the Supreme Soul but that the Supreme Soul God entered and spoke through him. It was only sometime after 1955 when the BKs started to mention yet another Hindu god's name. This time taking "Shiva" but, like the "Clever Businessman" he was (Murli reference) adding their own extra added twist to the design to make it unique. (Lekhraj Kirpalani was said to be a good designer of jewellery in his earlier days).

* Syncretism

The amalgamation or attempted amalgamation of different religions, cultures, or schools of thought.

** Bhaibands

The Bhaibands was said to be very secretive and jealous of each others business sources and would go to great lengths to hide it from others as knowing the source was the secret to their success.

Richard Francis Burton, the 19th Century occidentalist, explorer and ethnologist famous for immersing himself so much in his cultures of interest that he was accused of "going native", wrote:
Hindu religion is not to be found in a state of purity in Sindh. Hinduism here is mixed up with the heterogeneous elements of Islam, and the faith of [Guru] Nanak Shah. A Hindu will often become the murid (follower) of a Mussulman, and in some cases the contrary takes place ... all great Pirs revered by the Moslems have classical Hindu names”

(A Pir or Peer is a title for a Sufi master).

While in India, Burton became a proficient speaker of Hindustani, Gujarati, Punjabi, Sindhi, Saraiki and Marathi as well as Persian and Arabic. His studies of Hindu culture included time with a (real, not-BK) Brahman teacher and translating Sufi texts.

Burton was appointed to work in the Sindh where he began to travel in disguise and worked as an agent or spy for General Napier. One of his notorious cases was to participate in an undercover investigation of a brothel in Karachi, said to be frequented by British soldiers, where the prostitutes were young boys.

The Hindus of Sindh were not quite the most suitable examples of orthodox Hindus, as they were a meat-eating community in a largely vegetarian region.
User avatar

ex-l

ex-BK

  • Posts: 10661
  • Joined: 07 Apr 2006

Re: Sindhi Sikhs, an Amil connection?

Post28 Jul 2016

It is said good Sindhi studies, at least in the West, have been quite late to evolve and are only just starting to emerge. One such effort is 'Interpreting the Sindhi World: Essays on Culture and History', Oxford University Press, edited by Michel Boivin and Matthew A. Cook. To understand Brahma Kumaris, we need to start with understanding their roots in the Sindi Bhaibund merchant culture, and not be duped by idealized notions or "Hinduism", "Yoga" etc.

Recently, 'The Hindu' wrote about Saaz Aggarwal, a Sindhi migrant writer, blowing another BK mythology out of the water, that being the magical, God-inspired safety of the Om Mandli in Muslim Pakistan after Partition.

Bottomline is ... it was no big deal.

For example, Aggarwal visited a village with over 4,000 Hindus where the elders said they never left during Partition because their tribal chieftain promised them safety and fulfilled it too.

She concluded, “It proved to me that all you need for peace between two communities is good governance.”

-The Hindu writing about Saaz Aggarwal, a Sindhi migrant writer. See, Sindh: Stories from a Vanished Homeland (2012) by Saaz Aggarwal.
User avatar

Pink Panther

  • Posts: 1885
  • Joined: 14 Feb 2013

Re: Sindhi Sikhs, an Amil connection?

Post29 Jul 2016

The original source of the teaching is presented as being from "God" personally and directly rather than cobbled together from useful bits of other religions into something that sells. Studying the business practises of the Bhaibands, I tend to believe it was the latter. The Bhaibands were not creators but entrepreneurs. They bought the work of others cheaply, craftsmen and women, and then took it elsewhere, often internationally, to sell it elsewhere for high profits.

The thing about racial or social stereotypes is that they are based on noticeable and visible behaviour of a large number of those within a group. It may be true, for example, that more medieval jews were involved in work other than money-lending, but because they were conspicuous by being in that ‘disrespectful’ (at the time) field, money-lending became typically associated with Jews.

And those who are part of that ”finance sector” industry, or any industry, do develop their own culture, jargon, and way of seeing the world. That is, they end up a being a certain type of personality that seems to be, to them, normal, to the point of it being unconscious. Any ‘mercantile’ tendency or tendency to repackage and sell from other resources could easily happen unconsciously, a self-delusion of originality that plagues many "creative” people who lack the circumspection to see where, what and how they were influenced but have no lack of self-importance in claiming originality.
User avatar

ex-l

ex-BK

  • Posts: 10661
  • Joined: 07 Apr 2006

Re: Sindhi Sikhs, an Amil connection?

Post29 Jul 2016

Pink Panther wrote:And those who are part of that ”finance sector” industry, or any industry, do develop their own culture, jargon, and way of seeing the world.

One of the key indicators, I thought, was that the Bhaibands used the Amils as their scribes and accountants, and they developed secret coded languages to communicate internationally back to the Sind and across their networks to hide their business, and financial success, from others.

It made me think of the BKs re-working and use of Hindu terminology and subtle meanings given to standard language, giving it a new spin; but also a relationship which I think was reflected in the relationship between the Sindhi core and their Gujerati managers, e.g. Jayanti and Janki and their immediate entourage in London in the beginning.

I presume, the tendency has washed out a bit in recent year as they have internationalised.

The Bhaibands also had a tough apprentice system where newcomers were given a hard time, worked for little to nothing without any rights before being accepted as a "Brother" or a made man in the system. That too made me think of the way they run their trainee centre-in-charges rather than via a "professional" model.

Of course, other cultures had the same tendencies but it struck me that being a religion which based on a closed merchantile/trading model was something unique.
User avatar

Pink Panther

  • Posts: 1885
  • Joined: 14 Feb 2013

Re: Sindhi Sikhs, an Amil connection?

Post30 Jul 2016

On a similar note, if going off on a tangent, this may be another example of secret coded languages.

There was a southern US musician who visited here recently, a not-so-famous singer/songwriter son of a not-so-famous studio session player from the actually-quite-famous Muscle Shoals sound studios in Alabama. The interview was mostly about the famous people he’d met growing up.

The interview on the radio ended with the announcer asking what he thought of the Us elections and the Donald Trump phenomenon. He said in a slow southern drawl something like - ”You know, Bill Clinton is from Arkansas. He’s what we call one o’ them good ol’ boys. An’ they got this way of communicating that, you know, with a nudge or a wink or a nod, the other boys know what’s meant, though nothin' was actually said.

"Well, I wouldn't be surprised, you know that Trump and Clinton have done business over the years, an’ I’ve heard other southerners say this, we know how the game is played, if Bill called his friend Donald one day and he wouldn't have to say much, just a reminder of something, it’d be enough, to get Trump to run on the Republican side just to wreck their side and clear the way for Hillary.”

Given how amateurish and unprepared Trump seems - it wouldn’t surprise me either. Be careful what you wish for?

Return to The BKWSU