I like this site because it accomplishes something. It forces us (BKs, PBKs, ex-BK and non-BKs) to be more responsible and to think in a more rational human way and be sensitive enough to the feelings of others. I've noticed though that this site is not immune to the acts and effects of Bhakti. There is so much Bhakti in this site. Let's take the face value of some BK teachings. We have PROVED many years ago beyond reasonable doubt, that some teachings of BKs are false. Have PPKs PROVED anything at all to claim that their interpretation of Murlis is far better than BK's or is the truth? It still remains open. Advanced Knowldege is only a BELIEF. IT HAS NOT BEEN PROVEN AT ALL. Some BK Knowledge were proven to be false. Now, which is better in terms of validity, a false BK Knowledge or Advanced Knowledge that is only a belief? Take your pick. It just reminds me of a Christian Bhakti reading a Bible passage to prove their faith is the truth.
In my opinion, PBKs have not proved anything at all and so what is so advanced in the Advanced Knowledge? No fulfillment of Teachings means no proof. The proofs they are mentioning are only on the level of Murli words. But who knows if Murlis are Knowledge at all? Advanced Knowledge is just a correction of missed BK points, an exposition of altered Murli statements, a re-interpretation of BK points, a continued 100% belief in the Murlis after some elements in it have been proven false. It's just basically offering another faith-based risk investment.
But now let's discuss about principles and values (responsibility, honesty, humility, etc.), and share thoughts, experiences, insights, and opinions, then I think we can move better and further. That to me is the direct application of knowledge, devoid of Bhakti. We only need to know the principles and forget about that which cannot be proved in our lifetime. It's good to share one's opinion/beliefs, but we are sometimes deluded in the Bhakti of proving.
~tinydot
In my opinion, PBKs have not proved anything at all and so what is so advanced in the Advanced Knowledge? No fulfillment of Teachings means no proof. The proofs they are mentioning are only on the level of Murli words. But who knows if Murlis are Knowledge at all? Advanced Knowledge is just a correction of missed BK points, an exposition of altered Murli statements, a re-interpretation of BK points, a continued 100% belief in the Murlis after some elements in it have been proven false. It's just basically offering another faith-based risk investment.
But now let's discuss about principles and values (responsibility, honesty, humility, etc.), and share thoughts, experiences, insights, and opinions, then I think we can move better and further. That to me is the direct application of knowledge, devoid of Bhakti. We only need to know the principles and forget about that which cannot be proved in our lifetime. It's good to share one's opinion/beliefs, but we are sometimes deluded in the Bhakti of proving.
~tinydot