I like the way you added the letter 's' at the end of 'big Brothers' to change to mean from George Orwell to Nirwair-Brij Mohan-Karuna and Co. :)
The Vatican does not engage in floating its own companies and the priests are not it's salaried employees. The Indian Tax law and the dubious guild of select Chartered Accountants in India who colluded with Ramesh Shah ensured that the BKWSU can keep its cake and eat it too at the same time. Let's inspect how:
They can show any person, under their spell, as a contractual/temporary worker and account for the money under expenses, and at the same time escape the whole exhausting legal ordeal of provident-fund, working hours, tax deducted at source (TDS), health and dearness allowance, and other employee benefits.
As the subsidy is disbursed after the expenses has been made and the project is up and running, BKWSU will first pay out the money (to themselves) and then claim the entire amount from the government.
It sounds easy, but needs lot of work-around to cover up the trail. They earn donations, subsidies, and profits on the same project and also get recognition for doing such great innovative work and earn carbon credits which they again sell of to other companies and earn further. Wonderful!
You see it may be difficult for a normal trustee to use the money to run their homes, but in case of BK Leadership the trust itself is their home. Sweet!
Also, the trustees cannot pay salaries to themselves or their family members but they can surely create bogus vouchers of several surrendered drones and generate purchase orders through their own (dummy) companies at will. Let there be dark, and the light disappears in a snap. No wonder the BK Leadership feels it has become omnipotent!
ex-I wrote:You know the old FBI say, "Follow the money". Even the "impure" Kali Yugi Vatican is able to publish its accounts. Shouldn't "god's own" religion be setting higher standards
The Vatican does not engage in floating its own companies and the priests are not it's salaried employees. The Indian Tax law and the dubious guild of select Chartered Accountants in India who colluded with Ramesh Shah ensured that the BKWSU can keep its cake and eat it too at the same time. Let's inspect how:
- Q1. Are the surrendered Brothers at the BKWSU centers salaried employees or volunteers?
A1. That depends on what you got to offer. You do not need even to be surrendered to be a resident at a BKWSU center. We all know that in order to live at a center to provide Seva you can stay as long as the work demands at any of the centers with the oral or written permission of a Sister who is a Zone in-charge, Sub-zone in-charge or at least a Center in-charge, depending on jurisdiction and your rapport with the senior in the hierarchy.
You just need to be willing to provide free service, need to be an expert (electrician, carpenter, mason, accountant, graphic designer, video editor, engineer, doctor etc.), and need to sign a blank voucher for "tax purpose", if required. That's it!
Q2. How can a surrendered Brother/Sister be an employee of the BKWSU?
A1. They cannot be. But the memorandum of BKWSU allows them to pay any person (surrendered or not, real or artificial, like a company) who reasonably charges for any product or service that is above and beyond the scope of voluntary donation/service.
They can show any person, under their spell, as a contractual/temporary worker and account for the money under expenses, and at the same time escape the whole exhausting legal ordeal of provident-fund, working hours, tax deducted at source (TDS), health and dearness allowance, and other employee benefits.
- Q3. Do the persons who willingly play a party to the BKWSU's tax evading schemes not know that it is unethical or illegal?
A3. Free accommodation and food at God's house (Baba ka Ghar), a chance to do Seva and get recognition, and a surity to get a Palace in the new and pure world is sufficient for the brain-washed individuals to ignore the laws of the impure old world. As far as the companies of the Big Brothers are concerned they are more then happy to be paid by the Godly Teacher for their extra-curricular services!
Q4. How does the BKWSU benefit by paying to the companies of the Big Brothers under the current tax system which requires bank transaction (read white money) for amounts paid out above Rupees 5000?
A4. The companies perfectly allow BKWSU to convert the black money into white. Suppose the Big Brothers want to siphon 10 lac (1 million) rupees out of the donation that BKWSU receive, all they have to do is pay out the Goods and Services Tax (GST), say, 18% (1.8 lac rupees) and the rest (8.2 lac or eight hundred thousand rupees) are available and accounted for under expenditure at the same time.
- Q5. This is incredible, unbelievable, and too easy to be true. Can you substantiate your explanation with an example?
A.5 Sure. Say for example, the World Renewal Spiritual Trust (WRST) identifies a vendor (distributor) company which directly purchases from another manufacturing company some solar panels, ports, transmission installations for the Brahma Kumaris Ashrams, and say that this dummy company is run by or in collusion with the Big Brothers.
As the subsidy is disbursed after the expenses has been made and the project is up and running, BKWSU will first pay out the money (to themselves) and then claim the entire amount from the government.
It sounds easy, but needs lot of work-around to cover up the trail. They earn donations, subsidies, and profits on the same project and also get recognition for doing such great innovative work and earn carbon credits which they again sell of to other companies and earn further. Wonderful!
You see it may be difficult for a normal trustee to use the money to run their homes, but in case of BK Leadership the trust itself is their home. Sweet!
Also, the trustees cannot pay salaries to themselves or their family members but they can surely create bogus vouchers of several surrendered drones and generate purchase orders through their own (dummy) companies at will. Let there be dark, and the light disappears in a snap. No wonder the BK Leadership feels it has become omnipotent!
- Q6. How do the various wings earn/make profits?
A6. Let's say a Wing conducts awareness drive locally with a budget of a hundred thousand (1 lac) rupees. The BK center in that locality incurs all the expenses using the unaccounted for money in the donation boxes in the Murli Class. They then present the vouchers/receipts using the excel-based software and then the Head of the Wing will sanction the 1 lac rupees from the budget allotted to them by Nirwair. But in reality they never spent the allotted amount on the awareness drive. They spent the black money from their "Student-only" donation box.
- Q7. But did Ramesh Shah not ask all the accounts sevadharis (volunteers) way back in 2011 in the Conference Hall in Shantivan to account for every money they earn?
A7. Yeah right! Not only are the accounting meetings/seminars opaque as coal, they come with code language and cues only to be understood by the inner circle. So when Ramesh Shah said all the centers should keep an account of all the collection in the donation box, he meant do the data entry of only a set percentage (say 30%) of the actual collection. This way each and every cent/penny/paisa is traced and yet they leave no paper trail.
- Q8. This is an outrageous allegation on a deceased Big Brother. Do you think its a good idea to dare make such allegations?
A8. Oh! I'll dare speak against the BKs (Bogus Kumaris) because they are not even a non-profit organization in the first place. They charge for the retreats, seminars, conferences, corporate Spiritual Training sessions just like a profit-making organisation would...and....AND... you even pay service charge to the government.
The annual report of Emami Ltd. stating spiritual training workshops
by Brahma Kumaris in its Human Resource section. Whether they had to sponsor them or not is not clear.
by Brahma Kumaris in its Human Resource section. Whether they had to sponsor them or not is not clear.
- Q9. That is not true, they do not charge a fee for the corporate Spiritual Training sessions. BKWSU charges only for the books and CDs that we publish to sustain ourselves and pay only for the incurred cost. Can you prove your allegations?
A9. I am losing patience with these manipulative counter questions. The cost of a premium branded CD/DVD purchased in bulk at a wholesale rate will not cost more than Indian Rupees Eight (INR 8). How come then the BK centers charge between Rupees 30 to Rupees 1000 for the various offerings/DVD sets on a cheaper medium in India and much more abroad, may I ask? Same goes for books.
- Q10. Are you saying this because you yourself do not understand the true meaning of the acronym G.O.D. as Generator, Operator, and Destroyer, that is Brahma-Vishnu-and-Mahesh respectively?
A10. Why do I suspect these questions are from an ardent brain-washed BK? Let me give you another acronym to decipher, G.F.Y.!